Wednesday, July 11, 2012

The anomalous configuration of the chromium atom and related issues

Eric Scerri
UCLA
Department of Chemistry & Biochemistry
Los Angeles, CA
In this the third of my recent chemistry postings I want to consider topic that is related to my aufbau post,
I want to think about the question of the so-called anomalous configurations that occur is some d and f-block atoms (shown in yellow in the diagram below).  


  • As with the previous posts there is a strong connection with chemistry teaching.   This is because students are often taught that the configurations of chromium and copper, in particular, show anomalies from the way that orbitals are occupied as we traverse the transition element series. 
  • Chromium is said to have a configuration of 3d5 4s1 as opposed to 3d4 4s2.  Copper atoms are said to have a configuration of 3d10 4s1 as opposed to 3d9 4s2 as might have been expected from the general trend.  
  • Now there is good spectroscopic evidence for these anomalous configurations and this is not something I am proposing to question at least not in this post.[1]
  • I want to begin to look closely at the commonly given textbook explanation for why chromium has the configuration that it has.  
  • Textbooks almost invariably claim that the configuration of 3d5 4s1 possesses a half-filled sub-shell and that this is consequently more stable than the expected configuration of 3d4 4s2
  • I think that such an explanation is not very credible but worse, that it is ad hoc in a rather literal sense of the term.  
  • Of course it may be true that the energy of the anomalous configuration is lower than that of the expected one.  After all, why else would the anomalous one be observed if that were not the case?  
  • But is it because of the much-cited half-filled sub-shell stability?  I don’t think so and if you’ll permit me I will replace that mouthful by the abbreviation hfss to stand for half-filled sub-shell from now on.  
  • To see the limitations of such an explanation we can just look at the atoms in the second transition series that also have anomalous configurations.  There are in fact six of them,
  • Nb, Mo, Ru, Rh, Pd, Ag
  • I am going to ignore palladium and silver for the moment since they have filled d-orbitals and so cannot play any role in arguments considering the role of hfss.  
  • But of the remaining four cases, only one of them, molybdenum, has a hfss and not surprisingly perhaps it lies directly below chromium in the periodic table.  
  • Clearly then the adoption of an anomalous cannot be explained in general by appealing to a hfss.  
  • Here is another way of thinking of this issue by drawing on an approach that is often used in philosophy, and which goes by the name of “necessary & sufficient conditions”. 
  • Let me illustrate this with an example from chemistry-atomic physics.  As is well known, the identity of an element can be established unambiguously by from a knowledge of the atomic number of its atoms.  Moreover the relationship runs in the opposite sense too, in that a specification of an atomic number serves to identify the element in question. 
  • A philosopher looking at this situation might say that the possession of a particular value of Z is both necessary and sufficient for the identification of any element.  
  • Let me unpack this a little further because such language is not all that familiar in chemistry and physics.  If Z = 79, for example, the element must be gold.  We say that having an atomic number of 79 is sufficient (is enough) to ensure that the element must be gold.  
  • Conversely, if the element is to count as gold, it is necessary (essential) for it to have an atomic number of 79.  
  • The relationship runs in both directions without any exceptions.  Because of this fact, we can be confident that the use of atomic number really “nails” the identity of all elements.  
  • Now let’s go back to those pesky anomalous configurations and the possession or otherwise of ‘hfss’.
  • It turns out, rather disappointingly, that the possession of a hfss is neither necessary nor sufficient for an atom to display an anomalous configuration.  
  • The reason why it is not necessary should be clear from the fact that Nb, Ru, Rh all show anomalies but none of them in fact have a hfss.   The reason why it is not sufficient is that there are cases which do have hfss and yet do not show anomalous configurations.  This is true of manganese, technetium, rhenium and bohrium all of which have d5 configurations.[2]  
  • So where does this leave the commonly found explanation for the anomaly in chromium in terms of hfss stability?  Simply put – not in a very good place.  It so happens that chromium shows both a hfss and an anomalous configuration but this is seldom generalizable.  
  • In other words, the explanation is ad hoc[3] in the literal sense of having been brought to bear at a particular place (Cr) while being powerless in more general cases.
  • So please stop inflicting it on unsuspecting young students!
  • Have I labored the point a little?  Well perhaps I have but what I am trying to do is to ask chemistry instructors to think a little more deeply and more critically about the contents of chemistry courses and the manner in which material is presented to students.
  • Finally, I have said a good deal about how not to explain the configuration in chromium or other anomalous cases but have yet to make any positive suggestions.  But that will need to wait for a future blog.  There are in fact several better approaches.



Notes
[1] The question of precisely what to regard as the ground state configuration will be taken up in a future posting.

[2] In the f-block Eu and Am have hfss configurations of f7 but don’t show anomalous configurations.

[3] Ad hoc is Latin for “to here” in the sense of an explanation imported into a particular place with little concern for whether it applies in other places or situations.  Such an explanation is of course considered to be a ‘bad thing’.  

General References
Eric Scerri, A Very Short Introduction to the Periodic Table, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2011.
For other books please see,

42 comments:

  1. The way it was explained to me is that by having d5 and s1, Mo and Cr can avoid the energetic cost of putting two electrons into the same orbital. But one then has to explain why any elements with less than 5 d electrons should have s2. Philip Stewart

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for your comment Philip.

    Please see my earlier post regarding the aufbau applied in a sloppy way or an accurate way. The 3d orbitals are filled preferentially in all transition metals, contrary to what is said in the sloppy version. After adding one electron to 3d in Sc, the next two go into 4s in order to minimize the repulsion that would have occurred if all three had gone into 3d. This in turn is due to the greater compactness of the 3d orbitals as compared with the 4s.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hello Dr. Scerri,

    Is there any better way to explain the configurations of chromium and similar atoms with hfss?

    Thanks very much.

    - Kay Wu

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks for always being the source that explains things instead of just putting an unjustified answer out there. I loved this post.
    monolithic capacitors

    ReplyDelete
  5. There might some different approaches according to place or knowledge. Your skills depends on how you got an opportunity and where you have trained. Personal or professional training might distinguish between each other.Sale for Apple iPhone

    ReplyDelete
  6. Really inspirational to hear someone pursuing their dreams and becoming successful instead of following the traditional path. I have read your article about This topic. I think it's good and impressed to know your service. Thanks for share this Information.โรงพิมพ์ราคาถูก

    ReplyDelete
  7. I am delighted to come to such a wonderful blog. I am really very impressed to read from top to bottom. I read every single line and understand the essence of every single word. I appreciate all efforts.Dell Network N Series

    ReplyDelete
  8. I search many blog about the chromium but did not get many specific detail about the this topic but your blog have allot of information about my topic which I always searching.
    How to uninstall chromium

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have a longer account of the anomalies. If you wuld like a copy send me an E-mail Also see my website at http://www.ericscerri.com

      Delete
  9. If i may ask,what's the reason then for the anomalies??

    ReplyDelete
  10. I do believe in the power of question. ***** article

    ReplyDelete
  11. I welcome all the suggestion mentioned in this blog related to new learning skills. It is definitely going to help me to adopt new exited way of learning. I think, others will also feel helpful this blog for their needs.
    bioresonantie breda

    ReplyDelete
  12. Your post is providing some really good information. I liked its essence and enjoyed reading it. Keep sharing such important posts about this blog and its much more helpful for us .
    สมัคร Exness

    ReplyDelete
  13. Enthusiastic words written in this blog helped me to enhance my skills as well as helped me to know how I can help myself on my own. I am really glad to come at this platform.FORTIANALYZER 300D

    ReplyDelete
  14. Sometime few educational blogs become very helpful while getting relevant and new information related to your targeted area. As I found this blog and appreciate the information delivered to my database.FORTIAP 421E

    ReplyDelete
  15. Q....Camperthe expected energy of the electronic configuration of the Cu the real configuration?????

    ReplyDelete
  16. The depth of articles can easily be felt of this blog. Very precise and straight to the mark. I understood easily the matter of fact which the author of this blog wanted to deliver through his thoughts. Looking for more.
    bioresonantie ede

    ReplyDelete
  17. Surprising background experienced in everything sentence of this article. I made a decent attempt to get hint about how I could demonstrate substance of this blog. I must say, not much powerful but rather I surrendered every one of my weapons soon after understanding it.
    Boekhouder haarlem

    ReplyDelete
  18. I was reading your article and wondered if you had considered creating an ebook on this subject.Your writing would sell it fast.You have a lot of writing talent. Amar Mobile

    ReplyDelete
  19. Wow! This is the perfect blog I am looking this type of blog its awesome blog here , share great information about this topic. This informative blog helps many readers with their decision-making regarding the situation. Great articles and will look forward for more!bioresonantie haarlem

    ReplyDelete
  20. I found this blog after a long time which is really helpful to let understand different approaches. I am going to adopt these new point to my career and thankful for this help.bioresonantie amsterdam

    ReplyDelete
  21. Somewhere the content of the blog surrounded by little arguments. Yes it is healthy for readers. They can include this kind of language in their writing skill as well as while group discussion in college.bioresonantie groningen

    ReplyDelete
  22. Graceful written content on this blog is really useful for everyone same as I got to know. Difficult to locate relevant and useful informative blog as I found this one to get more knowledge but this is really a nice one.bioresonantie assen

    ReplyDelete
  23. This blog aware me about different programs which can become very useful for our friends and kids. Few websites provide combined courses and few of the are separately for single subject. Glad to get this information.bioresonantie breda

    ReplyDelete
  24. If I see a good post, you will not go without praising me, because every word written in the post you have written is very thoughtful, your way of writing is very beautiful and your views are also very good. This is a commendable post, as much as this post is praised, it is less, you should keep writing more beautiful posts in your life.
    Desi Girls Gurugram
    Escort Services in Noida
    Gurugram Call Girls Service
    Ordinary call girls in Gurugram

    ReplyDelete
  25. An enlightening post and strongly agree with the comments made. For sixth form students and undergraduates the electronic configuration of chromium and copper in terms of Hund's principle is mostly acceptable. Yes, I agree that it cannot be extended to other d and f block elements.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Wow! I have read your article and it's so good I will share it with family and friends. I just informed the travelers who want to know about who can apply for a Turkey e-visa? which is easy to get through the online process. Travelers who wish to travel to Turkey can apply for it.

    ReplyDelete
  27. The article you wrote is very interesting and easy to read and understand. I hope your audience enjoys it. Passengers who wish to visit Turkey and need a Turkish Visa can apply online at the website linked above.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Your active involvement and valuable contributions are deeply appreciated. Your efforts have played a crucial role in fostering a positive and encouraging atmosphere for everyone. Dreaming of exploring the wonders of India as a Canadian citizen? Leave behind the complexities of traditional visa applications and embrace the simplicity of the e-Visa. India e Visa for Canada Citizens- Experience the enchanting beauty of ancient monuments, indulge in the rich flavors of Indian cuisine, and immerse yourself in its diverse traditions. With a quick and hassle-free online application process, you can obtain your e-Visa from the comfort of your own home.



    ReplyDelete
  29. Nepal Introduces Digital Visa System For Seamless Travel Experience. This innovative initiative reflects Nepal's commitment to embracing technology and streamlining its immigration processes. With the new digital visa system in place, travelers can now apply for their visas online, eliminating the need for in-person visits to consulates or embassies. Check the website.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Your provided information is extremely beneficial to us. I appreciate you sharing this content. The World Top 12 Airports With The Highest Profitability are a testament to the remarkable success and efficiency of these aviation hubs. These airports have managed to achieve outstanding financial performance while providing top-notch services to millions of travelers worldwide.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Your posts are a true delight, engaging, and filled with invaluable insights. Getting Around Kenya: Essential Tips for Transportation offers valuable insights on navigating the country's transport options, ensuring smooth and enjoyable travels within Kenya's diverse landscapes.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Wonderful , I appreciate you because you are sharing this wonderful content with us. Botswana explorers! India exploration time? India e Visa for Botswana citizen; all you require is an e-Visa. This digital visa makes it simple to get a visa, whether it's for travel, business, or health. Have a current photo on hand and confirm that your passport is valid for six months. Prepare yourself for a memorable trip to India!

    ReplyDelete
  33. Your openness in sharing your wisdom and thoughts is sincerely admirable and deeply valued. I want to share some news for everyone. Eritrean explorers! Dreaming of India? India Visa for Eritrea Citizens. you can apply for an e-Visa online. Whether for tourism, business, or health purposes, this digital visa makes the process simple. Just ensure your passport has six months' validity, have a recent photo, and a payment method for the processing fee. Get ready for an incredible Indian adventure!

    ReplyDelete
  34. Stupendous! Your articles are absolutely astonishing. I'm determined to hunt down more articles with a similar quality. Thanks once more for sharing this invaluable information; it's highly advantageous.Cameroon Visa Fees and Processing Times: What You Need to Know. The visa fees can vary depending on the type of visa, the applicant's nationality, and the processing time chosen.

    ReplyDelete
  35. This paragraph is genuinely a good one. I am looking for more posts like this from you. I also like your website theme. Here is the important news Mexico Green Card. Are you excited to know more about it? I am sharing this here because everyone benefits from it.

    ReplyDelete